How to increase open rates and response rates in email
Cleaning the list, subject lines and preview text that get noticed, asking for replies, testing one change at a time and following up with quiet leads.
A list of 20,000 subscribers looks impressive in a dashboard. If only a few hundred of them open anything, it is a list of a few hundred people with a lot of dead weight attached, and that dead weight quietly hurts every email you send.
The good news is that open rates and response rates respond to a small number of changes, most of which take an afternoon. Here they are, roughly in the order they pay off.
Clean your email list first
Mailbox providers such as Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook watch how people react to your mail. When a large share of recipients never open, never click and occasionally mark you as spam, more of your future emails land in the spam or promotions folder, including those to your most loyal readers.
So the first step is subtraction:
- Remove addresses that hard-bounce. Most providers do this automatically; check that the setting is on.
- Build a segment of subscribers who have not opened or clicked in the last three to six months.
- Send that segment one or two re-engagement emails with a clear question: do you still want to hear from us?
- Remove everyone who does not respond.
It feels wrong to delete subscribers. The percentage of opens rises immediately, and the remaining list is the one that buys.
While you are in the settings, make sure your sending domain is authenticated with SPF, DKIM and DMARC. Since 2024, Gmail and Yahoo have required authentication and an easy one-click unsubscribe from bulk senders, and mail that does not meet the rules is more likely to be filtered or rejected. Mailchimp, Kit and most other providers have a step-by-step setup page for this.
Write subject lines people actually notice
The subject line decides most of the open. Three approaches work reliably for small senders.
Use the reader’s name, occasionally. A first name in the subject line stands out in a crowded inbox. Used every week, it stops standing out. Save it for emails where a personal tone fits.
Be specific. “Our November newsletter” tells the reader nothing. “Three caption formulas that got replies this month” tells them exactly what is inside.
Surprise them, honestly. A subject line that sounds like a confession or a plot twist gets opened out of curiosity. Picture a coach who sends an email titled with the reader’s name and “you made me laugh in a meeting”, then tells the story of a reply that made her day. That works because the email delivers on the line. A shocking subject that leads to a routine sales pitch works once, and then readers learn to ignore you.
For more on writing lines people click, the guide to headlines people can’t help but click on applies almost word for word to email.
Use the preview text
Below or beside the subject line, most inboxes show a short preview. If you leave it empty, the email program pulls the first words of the email, which is often “View this email in your browser” or an image description.
Every major email platform has a field for preview text (sometimes called preheader). Use it to finish the thought the subject line started. Subject: “The one post format nobody on your feed is using”. Preview: “It took four minutes to make and doubled the replies.” Together they make a small promise the email can keep.
Ask for a reply in the first email
The welcome email is the most-opened message most senders ever write. Use it to start a conversation: ask new subscribers one simple question, such as what they are struggling with right now or what made them sign up.
Two things happen. You learn what your audience actually wants, in their own words, which is better research than any survey. And people who reply have shown their mailbox that they want your mail; replies are one of many signals providers can use, although nothing guarantees a move from the promotions tab to the main inbox.
Answer every reply, even briefly. A list that hears back from a real person behaves very differently from one that only ever receives broadcasts. The best practices for email marketing cover the rest of a healthy welcome sequence.
Test one change at a time
Most email tools let you A/B test the subject line: send two versions to small parts of the list, then send the winner to everyone else. Test one variable at a time (subject, preview text, send time, sender name) or you will not know which change made the difference.
Keep a simple log of each send: date, subject, open rate, click rate, replies. Patterns show up after a dozen emails that no single report reveals.
A caution about open rates themselves. Apple Mail Privacy Protection loads images in the background for many Apple Mail users, which counts as an open whether or not the person read anything. Your open rate is therefore inflated by an amount you cannot see. Use it for comparing your own emails with each other, and make decisions on clicks and replies.
Send a short follow-up to quiet leads
Response rates matter most in one-to-one sales email: someone asked for a quote or a proposal, you sent it, and then nothing.
After two or three polite follow-ups, send a brief closing email. Put their first name in the subject line. In the body, say in one or two sentences that since you have not heard back, you will assume their priorities have changed and you will close the file, and that they are welcome to get in touch whenever the timing is better.
This kind of breakup email works because it removes pressure and asks for a simple answer. People who were meaning to reply often do so within a day, and a clear “no thanks” is still better than a lead left open for months. Leads who say “later” can move into an automated email sequence instead of manual chasing. Whatever the answer, mark it in your records the same day so the contact does not get a fourth follow-up by mistake.
Quick answers
What is the quickest way to increase open rates on a newsletter?
Remove subscribers who have not opened anything in several months, rewrite the subject line and preview text so they promise something specific, and send at the time your past reports show the most opens. Cleaning the list usually gives the biggest jump, because it removes people who were dragging the percentage down and helps your sender reputation.
Are email open rates still reliable?
Less than they used to be. Apple Mail Privacy Protection, introduced in 2021, loads email images automatically for many Apple Mail users, which can register an open even when nobody read the message. Treat open rate as a rough trend and judge campaigns mainly by clicks, replies and sales, which cannot be inflated that way.
What is a good response rate for email?
It depends heavily on the list and the type of email, so a single benchmark is misleading. A personal question sent to a small, engaged list can get many replies; a promotional broadcast to a large list may get almost none. Compare each email with your own previous sends rather than with published averages.
Does putting the first name in the subject line still work?
It can, as long as it is used sparingly and the data is clean. A name in every subject line stops standing out, and a broken merge field that shows a blank or the wrong name looks careless. Use it for emails where a personal tone fits, such as a check-in or a follow-up.
More in Email & funnels