Replyline About
Facebook4 min readUpdated

Facebook advertising with custom and lookalike audiences

What each audience type is, the sources you can build them from, how to set them up in Ads Manager, and when broad targeting beats both.

A dog groomer has 1,400 customers in her booking system and spends money on Facebook ads targeted at people interested in pets. That is a broad interest, so most of the budget reaches people who already have a groomer, live too far away or own a goldfish. The customer list is the more valuable asset. Uploaded to Meta, it becomes a custom audience she can retarget and, more usefully, the source for a lookalike audience of people who resemble her actual clients.

What a custom audience is

A custom audience is a group of people who already have a connection with your business. You build it from data Meta can match: actions on your website or app, engagement with your Facebook Page or Instagram account, video views, lead forms, events, or a list of customers you upload.

Custom audiences have three main uses. You can retarget them with ads that pick up where their last interaction left off, exclude them from campaigns meant for new people, and use them as the source for a lookalike audience.

The sources you can build from

In Meta Ads Manager, open the Audiences section from the main menu and choose Create audience, then Custom audience. You pick a source, and the main ones are:

  • Website: everyone who visited, people who visited specific pages, people who spent the most time, or people who triggered a specific event such as adding to cart. Needs the Meta Pixel or the Conversions API, and can look back up to 180 days.
  • Customer list: emails or phone numbers from your CRM or email platform, hashed before matching.
  • App activity: people who opened your app or took a specific action in it.
  • Video: people who watched a set share or duration of your videos on Facebook or Instagram.
  • Instagram account: people who visited your profile, engaged with a post or ad, sent a message or saved content.
  • Facebook Page: people who engaged with your page, its posts or ads, clicked a call-to-action button or messaged it.
  • Lead form: people who opened your instant form, including those who opened it but didn’t submit.
  • Events: people who responded to or interacted with a Facebook event.
  • Instant Experience: people who opened or clicked inside a full-screen Instant Experience ad.

Engagement-based sources need no code on your website, which makes video viewers and page engagers the easiest place to start. The retargeting and pixel strategy article shows how to sequence ads across them.

What a lookalike audience is

A lookalike audience asks Meta to find people who resemble a source audience. You choose the source, the country or region and a size. Meta then looks for people whose characteristics and behavior are similar to the people in the source.

Sizes run from 1 to 10 percent of the population of the chosen location. A 1 percent lookalike is the closest match and the smallest; 10 percent is broader and less similar. For small businesses in a single country, 1 to 3 percent is a common starting range.

To create one, go to Audiences, choose Create audience, then Lookalike audience, and pick a source. You need an existing custom audience (or a page or pixel as the source) before the option makes sense; Meta requires at least 100 people from a single country in the source.

Choosing the right source

A lookalike is only as good as the people it copies. The ranking that usually holds:

  1. Customers who bought, ideally your best or repeat customers
  2. Leads who completed a form or booked a call
  3. Website visitors to high-intent pages, such as pricing or checkout
  4. Video viewers who watched most of a video
  5. People who simply engaged with the page

A lookalike of everyone who liked a post finds more people who like posts. A lookalike of people who paid finds more people who might pay.

Refresh the source regularly. A customer list from two years ago describes the customers you had then.

Audience size and broad targeting

Older advice set a fixed ideal audience size. There is no such rule now, and Meta does not publish one. What matters is that the audience is large enough for the budget to spend without hitting the same people over and over, which the frequency and benchmark metrics will show you.

Also worth knowing: Meta’s delivery system has become much better at finding buyers on its own. With Advantage+ audience, your lookalikes and interests are treated as suggestions, and Meta may go beyond them if it predicts better results. For accounts with good conversion tracking, broad targeting sometimes beats a carefully built lookalike. Test both with the same ad and budget before deciding.

A practical setup for a small business

Start with three audiences. One custom audience of website visitors and engagers from the last 30 to 60 days for retargeting. One custom audience of existing customers for exclusions. And one 1 percent lookalike of your customers for prospecting, tested against broad targeting. The steps for launching the campaigns themselves are in the basics of running Facebook ads.

Before uploading any customer list, check how the people on it were collected and what they agreed to. If the sign-up form never mentioned advertising, ask a privacy adviser first.

Quick answers

What is the difference between custom and lookalike audiences?

A custom audience is made of people who have already interacted with your business, such as website visitors, video viewers or customers on an uploaded list. A lookalike audience is a new group of people Meta finds because they resemble a custom audience you choose as the source. Custom audiences are for retargeting; lookalikes are for finding new customers.

How big does a source audience need to be for a lookalike?

Meta requires at least 100 people from a single country in the source audience, but a lookalike built from a few hundred people is usually weak. A source of one to several thousand recent customers or high-intent leads tends to work better. Quality matters more than size: buyers beat page likers.

Are lookalike audiences still worth using?

Often, yes, but they are no longer the automatic first choice. Meta's Advantage+ audience and broad targeting can find buyers on their own when the pixel has enough conversion data. Test a lookalike against broad targeting with the same creative and budget, and keep whichever produces the lower cost per result.

Can you use an email list for Facebook advertising?

Yes. You can upload a customer list as a custom audience. Meta hashes the data before matching it to accounts, and you must accept its terms for customer lists and only upload people who agreed to be contacted under the privacy rules that apply to you. Not every address will match an account.

More in Facebook