Replyline About
Case studies4 min readUpdated

Case study: Celeb Boutique and the misused #Aurora hashtag

An online retailer tied a dress to a hashtag that was trending because of a mass shooting. What was posted, how people reacted, and the checks to run before joining any trend.

On the morning of July 20, 2012, a gunman opened fire during a midnight screening of The Dark Knight Rises at a cinema in Aurora, Colorado. Twelve people were killed and dozens more were injured. Within hours, “Aurora” was one of the most discussed words on Twitter as people shared news, searched for missing friends and expressed grief.

Around the same time, Celeb Boutique, an online fashion retailer selling celebrity-inspired dresses, saw the word trending and connected it to one of its own products.

What happened

Celeb Boutique sold a dress named Aurora, styled after one worn by Kim Kardashian. Its Twitter account posted a message saying that #Aurora was trending and that this was clearly because of its Kim K inspired #Aurora dress, followed by a winking emoticon and a link to the shop.

Nobody at the company appears to have looked at why the word was trending. One look at the hashtag would have shown news reports, eyewitness accounts and messages of condolence. Instead the brand dropped a product promotion into the middle of a national tragedy.

How people reacted

The response came fast and was furious. Twitter users replied in large numbers calling the tweet tasteless and offensive, and screenshots spread far beyond the brand’s own followers. News outlets picked up the story quickly, and it was reported in the same news cycle as the shooting itself.

For a small online retailer, this was more attention than the brand was used to, and all of it was negative.

How Celeb Boutique responded

The tweet was deleted, and the company posted an apology. Its explanation was that the social media team was not based in the United States and had not checked the reason for the trend before posting.

That explanation was honest, and it may have been true. It also made the problem plain: the account was being run by people who used trending topics as marketing hooks without reading them. Being based outside the US doesn’t stop anyone from clicking a hashtag before using it.

Thirty seconds of reading the hashtag would have prevented the whole thing.

The case became one of the most cited examples in social media training, alongside other hashtag failures such as the DiGiorno #WhyIStayed misstep two years later.

Why it keeps happening

Trend-jacking, attaching a brand message to whatever is trending, looks like an easy way to get reach. A trending topic has an audience already gathered. The risk is that the brand sees only the word, while everyone else sees the story behind it.

Three conditions make the mistake more likely. Social media is run by someone far from the audience, in time zone or culture. Posts are written quickly to catch a trend before it fades. And nobody else reviews a post before it goes out. Celeb Boutique had at least the first two. Other brands that learned the same lesson in public are collected in the case studies section.

The same logic applies to scheduled posts. A cheerful promotion queued days in advance can go out in the middle of breaking news; the McDonald’s Black Friday case shows a different way scheduling goes wrong.

What a team can check before posting

Read the hashtag before using it

Open the hashtag on the platform and scroll through the latest posts, not just the top ones. Then put the word into a news search. If a single word or name is suddenly trending, assume it is trending for a reason you don’t know yet.

Keep a list of terms to avoid

City names, dates and common words can become associated with a tragedy overnight. Agree as a team that any trending place name, date or person gets checked twice. The guide to the what, how and why of hashtags covers the basic checks for any tag.

Stay out of tragedies entirely

There is no clever way for a clothing shop to take part in a news story about a mass shooting. When the trend is about death, disaster or violence, the right brand post is no post. If you want to express sympathy, do it plainly and without a product, a link or a hashtag that promotes anything.

Pause the queue

When a major news event breaks, open the scheduler, whether that is Meta Business Suite, Buffer, Hootsuite or another tool, and pause anything promotional for the next day or two. Write down who on the team has the authority to do that, so it happens in minutes rather than after a meeting.

Have a second pair of eyes

For any post that uses a trend, a second person reads it before it goes out. In a one-person business, that second check can be a five-minute pause and a fresh look at the hashtag page.

Quick answers

What did Celeb Boutique tweet about Aurora?

On July 20, 2012, the online fashion retailer Celeb Boutique tweeted that #Aurora was trending and suggested it must be because of its Kim Kardashian-inspired dress called Aurora, with a winking emoticon. The name was trending because of the mass shooting at a cinema in Aurora, Colorado, that morning. The tweet was deleted after a wave of angry replies.

How did Celeb Boutique respond to the backlash?

The company deleted the tweet and posted an apology. It said its social media team was not based in the United States and had not checked why the hashtag was trending before using it. The explanation was widely reported, and it became a standard example of why brands must check a trend before joining it.

How can a brand avoid misusing a hashtag?

Before using any trending or unfamiliar hashtag, open it on the platform and read the most recent posts, then search the term in a news search. If the trend is about a tragedy, a disaster or a divisive event, stay out of it. Pause scheduled posts that might sit awkwardly next to the news.

Why do brands keep misusing trending hashtags?

Trend-jacking looks like easy reach, because a trending topic already has an audience gathered around it. The mistake becomes likely when the account is run by someone far from the audience in time zone or culture, when posts are written in a hurry to catch the trend, and when nobody reviews a post before it goes out. Celeb Boutique had at least the first two of those conditions.

More in Case studies