13 questions to ask an SEO professional before you hire them
What to ask about experience, methods, Google's rules, reporting and ownership of your accounts, plus the answers that should end the conversation.
An email lands in the inbox of a small business owner: “We noticed your website isn’t on page one. We can guarantee top rankings within 30 days.” Variations of it arrive every week, and some businesses pay. Months later the site has hundreds of junk links pointing at it and fewer visitors than before.
Hiring a search engine optimization professional can be one of the best investments a small business makes, or an expensive cleanup job. The difference usually shows up in the first conversation, if you ask the right questions. These thirteen are grouped by what they reveal.
Experience and who does the work
1. Is it just you, or do you work with a team or subcontractors? Plenty of excellent SEO consultants work alone. What matters is knowing who will actually touch your website. If content writing, link outreach or development is outsourced, ask to whom, and whether it happens in-house or overseas.
2. How long have you been doing SEO full time? Search has changed a great deal over the years, and experience through several major Google updates gives perspective. Length alone isn’t proof of quality, but someone who started last month is learning on your budget.
3. What types of businesses have you worked with? A consultant who has helped local service businesses knows different things from one who works with large online shops. Look for experience with businesses of your size, model and market.
4. Do clients stay with you, and can you share references? Long-term client relationships suggest the work delivers. Ask for two or three references you can contact directly, and ask those clients what changed, how long it took, and how communication worked.
How they plan to improve your site
5. What would you look at first on our website? A good answer mentions a review of the current site before any recommendations: technical health, indexing in Google Search Console, page speed, content quality, and the queries that already bring visitors. Anyone who proposes a fixed package before looking at the site is selling a product, not a service.
6. How exactly will you improve our visibility in search? Ask for specifics. Expect a mix of technical fixes, better or new content that answers what customers search for, internal linking and some form of earning links from relevant sites. Vague phrases like “our proprietary method” without examples deserve a follow-up question.
7. How do you get links to a site? This question separates careful consultants from risky ones. Good answers involve content worth linking to, digital PR, partnerships and local organizations. Bought links, link farms and mass directory submissions are red flags.
Google’s rules and local search
8. Do you follow Google Search Essentials? Google publishes its rules on Google Search Central. The guidelines formerly called Webmaster Guidelines are now Google Search Essentials, and they include spam policies that prohibit tactics such as automatically generated spam content, hidden text and links, and link schemes. A consultant who breaks them can get a site demoted in search results or removed altogether. You want someone who can name these policies and explains how they stay within them.
9. Are you experienced with local search? For a business that serves a town or region, local results matter as much as anything else. Ask about Google Business Profile, reviews, local citations and location pages, and ask for an example of a local client they have helped.
Measurement and reporting
10. How do you measure the success of an SEO campaign? Rankings for a handful of terms are a weak measure on their own. Better measures include organic traffic to important pages, impressions and clicks in Search Console, and, most of all, inquiries or sales that come from search. Agree on the measures before the work starts.
11. How often will you report, and what will the reports show? Monthly reports are common. They should explain what was done, what changed and what comes next, in plain language, not just a screenshot of a dashboard. Read the guide on how to write blog posts that rank well on Google to know what good content work should look like in those reports.
Contracts, access and ownership
12. What access do you need, and who owns the accounts and content? The business should own its website, domain, Google Search Console, Google Analytics and Google Business Profile, and grant the consultant access as a user. Any content written for the site should belong to the business once paid for.
13. What happens if we stop working together? Ask about notice periods, what gets handed over, and whether anything they built (links, pages, tracking) disappears when the contract ends. A clean exit is a sign of a consultant who expects to keep clients because of results.
Answers that should end the conversation
Walk away from anyone who guarantees a specific position on Google. Google’s own help article on whether you need an SEO says plainly that no one can guarantee a number one ranking. Be equally wary of secret methods, of anyone who wants to own your accounts, and of pricing that seems too low to cover real work.
If you are also outsourcing other marketing tasks, the overview of tasks you can outsource helps decide what to hand over first, and the questions for a video production company follow the same logic for video. Before signing with any SEO consultant, ask for a sample monthly report from an existing client with names removed, and read it as if it were about your business.
Quick answers
What questions should you ask an SEO professional before hiring?
Ask who will do the work, how long they have done SEO, which similar businesses they have helped, what they would check first on your site, how they build links, whether they follow Google Search Essentials, how they measure and report success, and who owns the accounts and content when the contract ends. Their answers should be specific and free of guarantees.
Is it a red flag if an SEO promises first place on Google?
Yes. Google's own guidance on hiring an SEO states that no one can guarantee a number one result on Google. Search results depend on many factors outside any consultant's control, including competitors and changes to Google's systems. A guarantee usually means the person either doesn't understand search or plans to use tactics that break Google's spam policies.
How long does SEO take to show results?
Usually months rather than weeks. Technical fixes can show up fairly quickly once pages are recrawled, but new content and authority take longer to build, especially in competitive markets. A good consultant gives a realistic timeline for your situation and agrees interim measures, such as indexed pages, impressions in Search Console and inquiries from organic traffic.
Who should own the website and Google accounts when you work with an SEO?
The business should. The website, the domain, Google Search Console, Google Analytics and the Google Business Profile belong in accounts the business controls, with the consultant added as a user. Content written for the site should pass to the business once it is paid for. Agree this in writing before work starts, so that ending the contract never means losing pages, data or tracking the business relied on.
More in Content